Light In Torah

Continuing from part one: what about 2 Corinthians 5:21? Isn't that Penal Substitutionary Atonement? "For our sake He made Him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in Him we might become the righteousness of God." (2 Cor. 5:21) Read with a substitutionary lens, that sounds like a celestial transfer: Jesus was innocent, sin gets imputed to Him, God treats Him as if He were a sinner, the penalty falls, the transfer is complete, and you go free. But that is not what Paul is doing. Reread 2 Corinthians with the rest of Paul's letters open. You will notice that for Paul, "made Him to be sin" is not a courtroom transaction. It names full  participation , not a transfer. Skip to Romans 8:3: "God sent His own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh and concerning sin, condemned sin in the flesh." Read carefully: God did not  condemn Jesus ; He  condemned sin in the flesh . Jesus had taken on the same human condition every one of us lives in. He entered the groun...

Atonement is not God's wrath being pacified by death. Atonement is the holy life overcoming the forces of death. Atonement is cleansing; it is the holding together of the relationship between heaven and earth, so that God's presence can dwell with His people. Jesus is the atonement for the whole world. John says His indestructible life is the answer to the death-dealing condition every human being lives in. He is the cleansing, the consecration, the living water. He is the meeting place where heaven and earth come together, and He is more than enough. That is more atonement than Penal Substitutionary Atonement ever offered. Some say this is absolute heresy. "You're going to answer for this one day. This is a demotion of Jesus. You're pulling back His glory. You're softening the cross." Here is what I actually said: His obedience was real. His faithfulness was real. He merited the fullness of the Spirit by walking the path no one else could walk. He confron...

Sometimes we limit ourselves by the way we examine the Scriptures. When we look at the Instructions (Torah), there is a tendency to turn it into a chronological history book, an all-encompassing science text, a theological manual of complete instructions, and a book of restrictive "dos and don'ts" that limit our freedom of expression and became obsolete after Yeshua's crucifixion. Personally, I think Yahweh's Instruction book is a never-ending guidebook. For example, as we move forward in counting toward the firstfruits of the wine, many have a tendency to think that Passover, Unleavened Bread, Firstfruits, Pentecost, etc., were all introduced in Leviticus 23 for the first time, or in Exodus 12 in story form, or because they are mentioned as "feasts of the Jews" a couple of times in the Gospels, that they are limited in their scope. And because they are defined in Leviticus ( Vayikra ) 23, we tend to stay away from them because that information is only f...

The Kansas City trip is wet, wet, wet! Water everywhere.  Water always makes me think of Miriam, whose name has water ( mayim ) built into it, but her name also contains bitter ( marah ).  Which one is it? Yes. If we are going to give Miriam a tribute from God's perspective, we will have to understand something about God Himself. One of His many names, which describes much more than His almighty character, is  El Shaddai  (God Almighty) (Gen. 17:1). Yet with this name, there is much more than His name implies—even though there is nothing mightier! We know that man was created in the image of God, both male and female (Gen. 1:26–28), but there is something extra special about the woman. She is the capstone to all of God's creation. She is the completer of man and the one to whom the man clings (Gen. 2:24). She is the one who takes away his aloneness (Gen. 2:18). The male produces the seed, but the woman brings it to life (Gen. 3:20), and she is the one who nurtures th...

We finished the Sabbath day with a gathering of believers who truly want to be part of "the five" (Lev. 26:6–8). Yahweh was and is so good to us by giving us the privilege of coming together as a portion of the body of Christ and celebrating the victory that Messiah gave to us, along with the instructions on how to live that out (1 Cor. 15:57–58; Deut. 1–3). Along this journey, individuals are going to find that all sorts of people are going to come against them (i.e., the world system, the religious systems, individuals with differing opinions). Though I would not consider the people coming against those individuals trying to keep the Torah-observant lifestyle as  enemies  in this instance, I do believe there are wonderful truths to apply from Yeshua's own words when He told us to "love your enemies, bless those cursing you, do well to those hating you, and pray for those abusing and persecuting you, so that you may be sons of your Father in heaven" (Matthew 5:...

This week's Torah portion,  Beha'alotecha  ("to ascend"), starts off with Aaron being commanded to ascend toward the lamps and light the seven lamps which will give light  over against  ( mool ) the lampstand, just as Moses commanded. It goes on to give us a description of the lampstand: how it is made of beaten work of gold, forming the shaft, the arms, and the flowers in the shape of an almond tree (Num. 8:2–4; Ex. 25:31–39). This is at least the third time that the lampstand description has been given (Ex. 25; Lev. 24), along with the value and importance of lighting it in the morning and the evening (Ex. 25; 37; Lev. 24). In the Middle East, the almond tree blossoms first, very early in the spring. However, it is the last of the trees to be harvested before Sukkot. And as we see in California, it requires a tremendous amount of water in order to bring forth its fruit. The comparison of our lives to the menorah is easy to make :-) The shape of the lampstand is sim...

Isaiah 53 does not end with a crushing death. It ends with His days prolonged and the will of the Lord prospering in His hand. "After the anguish of His soul, He shall see and be satisfied." That is not the language of remaining dead. He goes down, is cut off, and is buried with the wicked—but death does not have the final word. The writer of Hebrews names what is happening here: He holds His priesthood by the power of an indestructible life (Hebrews 7). That is the same life Peter preached: "It is impossible for death to hold Him" (Acts 2). Put this together: the servant carries our sicknesses, our pains, and the forces of death we cannot carry. He goes into the wreckage where sin has done its worst. He bears it. He dies under that weight. And then the life that emerges is stronger than the death He carried. That is the center of Isaiah 53—not God as punisher. And that is not a smaller story than penal substitution; it is much bigger. Finally, verse 12: "He bo...

"He was pierced for our transgressions, crushed for our iniquities." That is the traditional phrasing. "The chastisement of our peace was upon Him, and by His stripes we are healed." The Hebrew word for "chastisement" here is  musar .  Does anyone know what  Musar  is?  It is a study of Jewish ethics, but also teaching and discipline. Notice the little word "for"—pierced  for , crushed  for . Let us apply our first tool: each can mean "on account of." But look at this: "The  musar  of our peace was upon Him." Most English Bibles render this as "chastisement" or "punishment," which sounds courtroom-like. Yet  musar  is a broader word rooted in father-son formation. Proverbs 3 says, "My son, do not despise the  musar  of the Lord." Yes, it can include painful correction, but  musar  is not a retributive penalty. The Greek translators of the Septuagint chose  paideia —training, formation, discipline—...

Continuing from yesterday:  "You meant evil against me, but God meant it for good in order to bring about what is happening in this state—to preserve many people alive." (Genesis 50:20) Did Joseph suffer? Yes—in the pit, slavery, false accusations, prison. His brothers were truly against him. Their evil was not theatrical; it was not just a show. And God used that suffering. The same suffering that came from human evil became the doorway through which God preserved life. But notice what is not in that story: God did not author the brothers' evil. He did not need their violence. He was not waiting for an innocent person to be punished before He could bless His people. The brothers meant harm; God overcame it and made that harm serve life. PSA (Penal Substitutionary Atonement) says the violence satisfies God. The Joseph pattern says God overcomes violence and turns it toward good. That is the pattern: people do bad things; God means it for life. Remember what we said about ...

For the past fifty days, we have focused our attention on grace—how proud God is of us through our obedience—on past, present, and future aspects of salvation, and on four weeks devoted to blood through the sacrificial system, adding additional thoughts to John 1:29: "Behold, the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world." One major focal point is that He goes ahead of us, not instead of us. That is powerful, and that phrase will continue to do work for us in this week's Isaiah 53 study. However, this Isaiah 53 text is likely what people have been waiting for—politely and silently. I have received very little pushback or critique on these fifty days of study, which has surprised me. Maybe that means something good—people are hearing and listening. But there is a passage, a section of Scripture, that I think many people would say blows up everything I have been saying. It is in the book of Isaiah, chapter 53—the Suffering Servant. If someone wanted to push back on th...

  I left you with a question on Shabbat morning, the 49th day of counting the Omer, and here we are on the 50th day—Pentecost. If lambs do not remove sin in the sacrificial system, what is John saying? Why does he say it? John knows lambs are not the animals used at Yom Kippur. He knows the Passover lamb is not a sin offering or a purification offering for the sanctuary. So why does he say, "Behold the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world" (John 1:29)? Because John is doing what the prophets do: bringing multiple streams together into a powerful statement. "The Lamb of God" draws us into Passover, Exodus deliverance, and the birth of a redeemed people. It draws us into the prophetic promise that God Himself would remove sin, end exile, cleanse His people, give them a new heart, and pour out a new Spirit. These are not competing ideas. John is saying, "Behold the Lamb of God"—the place where these ideas converge in Yeshua. Speaking from within th...